At EMNLP 2024, the Best Paper Award was given to "Pretraining Data Detection for Large Language Models: A Divergence-based Calibration Method". The paper addresses Membership Inference Attacks (MIAs), a key issue in machine learning related to privacy. The authors propose a new calibration method and introduce PatentMIA, a benchmark utilizing temporally shifted patent data to validate their approach. The method initially seems promising: it recalibrates model probabilities using a divergence metric between the outputs of a target model and a token-frequency map derived from auxiliary data, claiming improved detection of member and non-member samples. However, upon closer examination, we identified significant shortcomings in both the experimental design and evaluation methodology. In this post, we critically analyze the paper and its broader implications.